Ten years ago I shared a recipe for Pimento Cheese. And for the past decade it's been my go-to recipe. Not unlike most 'firsts', it will always be a favorite. However, on a fun-filled, bourbon tasting inspired girl's trip to Louisville, Kentucky last week I discovered a twist on this beloved, classic spread. While having cocktails before dinner at Proof on Main, one of my friends ordered the pimento cheese appetizer. Considering the 150th running of the Kentucky Derby was just two weeks away, it couldn't have been a more perfect choice. Served in small canning jars, the Pimento Cheese was topped with Red Pepper Jelly. The contrast of flavors of the creamy, tangy cheese mixture with the sweet, spicy red pepper jelly was absolutely brilliant.
As it turned out, I came home from the trip with more than multiple bottles of bourbon and a t-shirt from Churchill Downs. I returned home inspired. Rather than simply topping my pimento cheese recipe with red pepper jelly, I thought maybe I would make a new version of this highly addictive spread.
This time around I added a small amount of cream cheese to the mixture, omitted the green onions, was slightly more heavy handed with the hot sauce, and used smoked paprika instead of cayenne. However, I did not even consider swapping out the sharp (yellow) cheddar cheese with any other cheese. Nor did I even consider using anything other than Duke's mayonnaise. I was more than pleasantly surprised to discover how divinely delectable this new version was. And that was even before I topped it with the red pepper jelly!
Serving the Pimento Cheese with Red Pepper Jelly on crostini instead of on classic white bread also turned out to be an ingenious idea! It may have been forty eight years since I first tasted Pimento Cheese at the Kentucky Derby, but my affinity for it hasn't changed. Except maybe now I am even more smitten with it.
With the Kentucky Derby just around the corner (it's the first Saturday in May), now would be the perfect time to make this cheesy, tangy, sweet, spicy spread. This homemade version will invariably be far superior to anything you might find in the grocery store! Serving it in canning jar creates an irresistible, rustic presentation. There may no better way to pay homage to this celebrated humble spread.
Recipe
Pimento Cheese with Red Pepper Jelly
Ingredients
8 ounces (227g) sharp cheddar cheese (see notes), coarsely grated
1/2 to 2/3 cup Duke's mayonnaise
4 ounce jar of pimento peppers, drained
1/2 teaspoon black pepper
1/2 teaspoon Kosher salt
1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika
2-3 dashes hot sauce
2 ounces cream cheese, softened
Several Tablespoons of Red Pepper Jelly
Crostini made from a baguette (using either the oven or grill method)
Directions
1. In a large bowl, combine the grated cheddar cheese, cream cheese, 1/2 cup mayonnaise, pimento peppers, smoked paprika, Kosher salt, black pepper and hot sauce. Use a large spoon or spatula to combine. Mix until you have a well combined, creamy spread. If it's not creamy enough, add in a little more mayonnaise and blend again. Note: I usually end up using 2/3 cup of mayonnaise.
2. Transfer the mixture your serving containers and chill in the refrigerator for several hours or overnight.
3. When ready to serve, top with a thin layer of Red Pepper Jelly (use 2-4 tablespoons depending on the size of the jar). Serve with some oven baked or grilled crostini.
Notes: (1) Do not buy pre-shredded cheese! Buy a good quality sharp cheddar cheese (I used Tillamook) and grate it on the large holes of a grater. (2) I used Stonewall Kitchen's Red Pepper Jelly, but use any good quality one. Or use one you make from scratch. (3) If you can't find Duke's Mayonnaise, use a homemade mayonnaise or Hellman's (Best Foods) Mayonnaise. Whatever you do, don't use Miracle Whip. (4) Use smaller or medium sized canning jars for serving. (5) If you have any leftovers, use to make Pimento Cheese Toast. A slice of bread spread with the pimento cheese and topped with softly scrambled eggs. Or make a grilled pimento cheese sandwich!
Grazing horse in rural Kentucky and Churchill Downs (April 2024)
