With a dozen recipes for shortbread cookies on the blog, why on earth would I possibly add one more? Well, the truth is I have been debating for more than a year on whether or not I would even share this recipe with you. Not because I have any plans to open up a bakery or cookie catering business. Not because it's such a difficult cookie to make that no one would be enticed to make it. Not because I am launching a Substack and plan on charging for this recipe. And definitely not because I am going to write a cookbook someday and am holding onto to this recipe until then. No, not for any of those reasons. So exactly what has kept this absolutely BEST shortbread cookie in my 'recipe vault'?
This is the first recipe where the measurements are only in either grams or teaspoons. For all of my friends who live outside of the United States this wouldn't actually be a good enough reason to hold out on sharing a recipe. And for all of my friends who I have been able to convince over the past ten years that weighing out ingredients when baking is the preferred, best, only way to bake, this too would be a lame reason for keeping this drop-the-mic, throwdown worthy cookie recipe to myself. But for anyone else who still uses measuring cups when baking, this may not be a recipe you are inspired to make. Unless of course, you tasted them and then instantly converted to becoming the baker who weighs their ingredients/ And you finally discover firsthand just how much of a huge difference it makes in the taste, texture, and consistency of your baked confections.
The second, and maybe the most important, reason I have not let this recipe see the light of day is because there is one (potentially deal breaking) ingredient not easily accessible at the grocery store. An ingredient that turns a better than ordinary shortbread cookie into an incredibly spectacular, swoon worthy, throw down winning worthy, could make you famous one day shortbread cookie. And that ingredient is the flour. Yes, the flour. Because flour can make a significant difference in baking as not only does its' protein content highly influence structure, texture and flavor, it turns out that how flour is milled matters too. Stone milled versus rolled all-purpose flours can result in richer, nuttier, more flavorful baked goods. In other words, stone milled flours are a baker's best friend. Last, but not least, the kind of wheat used in the flour has a significant influencer on flavor. What I discovered in the last year is that Janie's Organic All-Purpose Flour, a high-quality flour, stone milled in a small town in central Illinois, is one of those flours that significantly affect the quality, taste and flavor of baked goods. Especially in these Shortbread Cookies.
After a great deal of deliberation, I decided perceived inaccessibility to a key ingredient wasn't a good enough reason to keep this recipe to myself. Because even if you can't find it where you live, it can be ordered directly from Janie's Mill. In a day in age where we think nothing of ordering online, being able to purchase an organic all-purpose flour from a family-owned farm in Illinois from your phone or computer truly makes the world flat. And, without exaggeration, this flour might also enable you to make the most spectacular shortbread cookies in the universe. Or at least worshipped amongst your family and friends.
The dough for this shortbread comes together easily and doesn't need chilling. Additionally, it is completely unnecessary to sift the flour. As it turns out, sifting flour when making dense, crisp cookies versus when making softer, lighter cookies like macaroons, is a wasted step. Today's flours are much more refined than they were in the past, thus eliminating the clumps that sifting process had provided. Whisking the flour and salt together provides the necessary aeration and will break up any rogue clumps.
The shortbread cookies should be rolled out to a thickness of somewhere between 3/8" and 1/4". Baking time might vary slightly between these two thicknesses.
How much sparkling sugar you put on the rolled out dough will depend on whether or not you plan to dip or drizzle them in chocolate. For a non-chocolate dipped cookie, be more generous with the sparkling sugar. For a chocolate dipped cookie, you might want to (but don't have to) sprinkle the sugar on one half of the cookie, saving the other half for dipping.
These Shortbread Cookies are absolutely delicious without the additional chocolate and/or chopped nuts. However, the addition of the chocolate and nuts significantly raises the deliciousness bar! I have dipped them in both milk/dark chocolate and in white chocolate. Personally, I like the flavor combination of the rich buttery shortbread cookie and the creaminess of white chocolate.
If I ever go back to making cookie boxes at Christmas, these will definitely be one of the cookies included in them. Although, this Shortbread Cookie shouldn't be pigeon-holed in the Christmas cookie category. It's a cookie so divinely delicious; it's one you should be making all year round. These Shortbread Cookies would make great hostess gifts, get well gifts, housewarming gifts and/or should be brought to your book clubs. They would also be great to just have on hand to enjoy with a cup of tea or coffee.
They say 2026 will be a year characterized by new beginnings. I genuinely hope making the recipe for these Shortbread Cookies aka the Best Shortbread Cookies is one of many of your new beginnings. While I don't where this blog is headed in the year ahead, it's possible there will be more recipes that get you to rethink (i.e., change) how you cook, how you bake, and how you entertain. We can grow and change together. I wish you only best days ahead in 2026!
Recipe
Shortbread Cookie aka the Best Shortbread Cookie
Makes 22-24 4 inch cookies
Ingredients
340g unsalted butter, highly recommend a European style butter (see notes)
150g granulated sugar
2 1/2 teaspoons good quality vanilla
475g organic all-purpose flour (see notes)
1/2 teaspoon Kosher salt
Sparkling sugar (not granulated sugar)
226g white, milk or dark chocolate, melted
Finely chopped pistachios or toasted hazelnuts
Directions
1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees (F). Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper. Set aside.
2. In the bowl of a standing mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, beat the butter until creamy (approximately 2-3 minutes).
3. Add in the granulated sugar and beat for another 3-4 minutes. Mixture should be smooth and fluffy.
4. Beat in the vanilla just until blended.
5. Whisk together the flour and the Kosher salt. Add in the dry ingredients in three additions. Beat until the dough comes together and begins to pull away from the side.
6. On a lightly floured surface scoop out half of the dough. Roll out to at least 3/8" thickness but not more than 1/4" thickness. Cut out with preferred cookie cutter shape. Transfer cookies to one of the prepared baking sheets. Sprinkle with sparkling sugar.
7. Place in oven and bake for 20-22 minutes or until the edges of the cookie have browned. Rotate cookie sheet midway through the baking process.
8. Remove cookies and allow to cool on the cookie sheet for another 6-8 minutes. Then transfer to a cooling rack.
9. Repeat the rolling, cutting, sprinkling with sugar and baking with the remaining dough.
10. When all of the cookies have cooled completely, dip half of them in melted white chocolate. Before the chocolate sets, sprinkle with finely chopped pistachios or hazelnuts.
11. After the chocolate has completely set, serve and enjoy! Or package up into containers and/or cellophane bags and share with friends!
Notes: (1) For the absolute best shortbread cookie, use only Janie's Mill Organic All-Purpose Flour. You can find it at some specialty grocery stores and/or at some bakeries. Or you can purchase it online. Once opened, store the unused flour in the refrigerator. (2) The amount of butter used equates to three sticks of butter. Use either all European style butter (i.e., Kerrygold) or 2 sticks of a European butter and 1 stick of another good quality unsalted butter. Both options will yield great results. (3) You can make this shortbread using King Arthur's Organic All-Purpose Flour but I can't guarantee that everyone will be doing handstands when they eat this cookie. (4) This is the cookie cutter from Williams-Sonoma I used when making these cookies.
The Grand Tetons, one of my happy places. September 2024.

.jpg)


.jpg)



.jpg)



































