Every now and then I surprise myself. While I am almost always happy with how a new recipe turns out, there have only been a few times when I wanted to stand in the middle of street with a megaphone and announce to the neighborhood that I have just created the absolutely best thing in the universe. This would be one of those rare 'forget having any sense of humility' moments. Rather it would be one of those unabashedly, shamelessly hubris moments. The creation of these Levain Style Lemon Cookies has unleashed a monster in me. Because this is absolutely, unequivocally the BEST, GREATEST, MOST INSANELY DELECTABLE, CRAVEWORTHY, GORGEOUS lemon cookie on the planet. Possibly the universe. There I said it. I have never been so bold in my entire life. But this cookie, well this freaking amazing cookie has brought out the best of the worst in me.
I could take complete responsibility for the creation of this cookie had I not been gently pushed (in the best of ways) by my dear friend Linda. It was she who asked me months ago if I could re-create the Levain Lemon Cookie as she absolutely loves all things lemon flavored. In spite of having created several Levain style cookies for the blog, I wasn't exactly sure I could replicate this one without creating a 'break the bank' confection. Lemon flavored chips were the sticking or rather should I say sticker shock point. Once I learned others had used white chocolate chips as an alternative, I knew my next biggest challenge would be to create a cookie having the 'right' amount of lemon flavor. Not one overpowering or cloyingly sweet with the flavor of lemon, but one having a more subtle, but still discerning lemon flavor to be detected in each mouthwatering bite.
There were a myriad of options to consider for infusing lemon flavor into the cookie dough. Freshly squeezed lemon juice, lemon zest, lemon extract, lemon paste and/or any combination of the aforementioned. My gut was telling me to use only lemon zest and lemon paste. Some will say there isn't any difference between lemon extract and lemon paste, but I happen to be one that disagrees. The thicker lemon paste delivers a much better, less acidic lemon flavor. And while lemon juice can add some bitterness. lemon zest infuses concentrated amounts of sweet, citrus flavor. But figuring out the quantities of each was going to take a bit of thinking.
Having made Levain style cookies before I knew I would be using a combination of all-purpose and cake flours, granulated sugar, light brown sugar, baking powder, baking soda, Kosher salt, eggs (one large egg, one large egg yolk), unsalted butter, and alot of chips. Compared to my other Levain style cookies, this recipe uses different amounts of sugars, baking powder, baking soda, Kosher salt and chips. Some less, some more. I knew I would get a sense of whether or not I made the right decisions when I mixed and then tasted the batter. If there was thing I learned very long time ago is that 'the batter never lies'. If the consistency doesn't look or feel right, the cookie won't turn out right. If the batter doesn't taste right, the cookie won't have an optimal flavor. In other words, a bad batter isn't salvageable.
To chill or not to chill the dough was yet another decision I needed to make. I decided to let the balls of dough chill for slightly over an hour. Just enough time for the to dough rest and hold its' shape when it went into a hot preheated oven. I knew i didn't want the tops of my cookies to be smooth, so I used the roll into a ball, break in half, bring the halves together method so I would have cookies with that beautiful bakery style craggle-y top.
This recipe makes 8 ginormous cookies. In order to get them to bake evenly, the balls of dough must be weighed. Each ball of dough weighs a little more than 6 ounces. Because they are so huge, it's important to bake only four cookies at a time. When baking, I decided to use the two tray method. One tray turned upside down and the tray with the cookie balls set on top (so two tray bottoms are touching one another). I am not certain I can explain the science behind why this works with large over-sized cookies, but it does.
Baking time for the Levain Style Lemon Cookies ranged from 17-18 minutes in a preheated 375 degree (F) oven or just until the cookies were a beautiful golden brown. Key to their doneness was to allow the cookies to rest on the hot cookie sheet for at least 8-10 minutes before transferring them to a cooling rack. The heat from the pan helps to continue to bake the cookies without drying them out or burning their bottoms. Additionally that rest time makes it easier to transfer them to a cooling rack.
The texture and flavor and these cookies are perfect. You can definitely smell and taste the flavor of the lemon. We absolutely loved the level of lemon flavoring in theses cookies. It was detectable, yet subtle in the best of ways.
If the Pancake Princess ever did a Levain Style Lemon Cookie bake-off I want to enter this recipe. If I ever wanted to brighten the day of friend who loved lemon flavored cookies, I would bake up and deliver a batch of these cookies. Or if I ever wanted to enter (and win) a cookie contest, I would make these cookies. Which speaks volumes since I absolutely love my chocolate chip cookies.
In all seriousness, I take a big risk when I shamelessly gush about how fabulous these cookies are. In part because not everyone follows 'the' recipe, measures the ingredients, or bakes in an elevation similar to the one in the midwest. Yet, in spite all of these factors, I will end by saying this may be BEST, MOST SCRUMPTIOUS, TO DIE FOR, SHOW STOPPING, DIVINE cookie I have ever made in my entire life. There I said it!
Recipe
Levain Style Lemon Cookies
Makes 8 humungous cookies
Ingredients
1 cup (226g) unsalted butter, room temperature
3/4 cup (150g) granulated sugar
2/3 cup (134g) light brown sugar
1 large egg
1 large egg yolk
Zest from one large lemon
1 1/2 teaspoons Lemon Paste (See Notes)
2 1/4 cups (293g) all-purpose, unbleached flour
1 cup (118g) cake flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
3/4 teaspoon baking soda
3/4 teaspoon Kosher salt
16 ounces (453g) white chocolate chips
Directions
1. In the bowl of a standing mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, beat butter for approximately 1 minute.
2. Add in the granulated sugar and brown sugar. Beat until light and fluffy (approximately 4 minutes).
3. Add in the egg, egg yolk, lemon zest, and lemon extract. Beat until well blended.
4.In a medium sized bowl, whisk together the all-purpose flour, cake flour, baking powder, baking soda and Kosher salt. Add in the dry ingredients to the mixing bowl. Beat on low-medium speed until the dry ingredients are almost all incorporated.
5. Add in the white chocolate chips. Mix until completely blended (and no white streaks of flour remain).
6. Roll in 8 balls, slightly more than 6 ounces (171g) each. Break each ball in half and press sides into each other to create a round ball with a top of the craggle-y edges.
7. Place balls of dough onto a platter or baking sheet. Cover and chill for 60-90 minutes.
8. Preheat oven to 375 degrees (F).
9. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper. Note: You will bake only one sheet at a time (unless you have a double oven).
10. Place 4 balls of dough on a baking sheet.
11. Turn a baking sheet upside down. Place the baking sheet with the balls of dough on top of it. Insert onto the middle rack of the oven and bake for 17-18 minutes or until the cookies are golden brown. Note: Rotate the baking sheet midway through the baking process and check for doneness at the 16 minute mark.
12. Remove from the oven and let the cookies remain on the hot cookie sheet for at least 8 minutes before transferring to a cooling rack.
13. Bake the remaining cookie sheet.
14. Let the cookies cool before devouring.
15. Store the baked cookies at room temperature. Ideally store them individually in a cellophane bag or waxed bag. To recreate the just out of the oven taste, reheat in the microwave at high for 8-10 seconds.
Notes: (1) I used the lemon paste from Neilson-Massey. (2) If you would like a slightly stronger lemon flavor either increase the lemon paste to 2 teaspoons or add some additional lemon zest. (3) I used the Ghiradelli white chocolate chips.
Wildlife in Yellowstone, May 2024
