Honey & Herb Baked Fontina & Gruyere in Puff Pastry

 

Rather than serving only one appetizer when hosting a dinner party, I have a tendency to serve an array of them. While isn't necessarily a bad thing, but sometimes all we need is just one show-stopping, appetite whetting, crowd pleasing appetizer. And this gorgeous, cheesy Honey & Herb Baked Fontina & Gruyere in Puff Pastry is one heck of a stunner. Not only does it promise to make all of your cheese loving friends deliriously happy, it will exceed all of their expectations. Worthy of putting in your appetizer rotation and ideal for a gathering of six to eight people, you too might come around to the idea that less is more. I know I finally have.

After everyone is finished dipping their crackers or sliced baguettes into the hot, gooey cheese, cut the cheese, honey, and herb laden golden, flaky puff pastry into wedges. Drizzled with some additional honey, you get double the pleasure from just one appetizer!  If there was ever a time when you don't want a single bite to go to waste, this would be one!

In addition to being able to assemble this appetizer earlier in the day, you get to decide on your cheese and herb ratios. You can use equal parts of cubes of Fontina and Gruyere cheeses or you can use a 2 to 1 ratio (I used the 2 Fontina to 1 Gruyere ratio). Both thyme and rosemary pair perfectly with these two cheeses. You can use a combination of the two or you can use one or the other (I used a thyme/rosemary combination, slightly heavier on the thyme). Puff pastry, minced garlic, honey, an egg and coarse sugar round out the ingredients needed.

My favorite, go-to frozen puff pastry is made by DuFour. While it's definitely not inexpensive, it's texture and flavor are heavenly. DuFour's puff pastry comes in a rectangular shape, but it can easily be cut into a square. You can use small cookie or canapé cutters to cut shapes out of the extra piece of puff pastry. I used a small star cookie cutter to decorate the top of the folded pastry.

Once the pastry is folded over the cheese, honey, garlic and herb mixture, it's brushed with a lightly beaten egg and generously topped with some coarse (not granulated) or sanding sugar. If not baking immediately, keep chilled in the refrigerator. Note: If chilling, wait to brush on the egg wash until ready to bake.

The Honey & Herb Baked Fontina & Gruyere in Puff Pastry bakes in preheated 425 degree (F) oven for 30-35 minutes or until the pastry is golden brown and cheese completely melted. The cheese should be hot and gooey.

Garnish with some fresh herbs (maybe even some edible flowers) and drizzle with some additional honey before serving. I loved pairing the (pricey) Rainforest Crackers with it, but Trader Joe's sells a less expensive version. A sliced baguette would be an equally good serving option.

This creamy, melted Fontina and Gruyere cheeses encased in an egg-washed, sugar crusted, flaky puff pastry is a sinfully delicious symphony of flavors. It has the perfect balance of sweetness, savoriness, creaminess, and flakiness. Having all of the hallmarks of a show-stopping, exceptional appetizer, it is destined to be a huge hit at your next gathering. 

Recipe

Honey & Herb Baked Fontina & Gruyere in Puff Pastry

Serves 6-8 as a hearty appetizer

Ingredients

14 ounce box of puff pastry, thawed (i.e., DuFour)

14-16 ounces of a mixture of Fontina and Gruyere cheeses, cut into 1/2" cubes (see notes)

2 large garlic cloves, finely minced

1 1/2 Tablespoons of fresh thyme and rosemary, minced (see notes)

3 Tablespoons good quality honey, plus more for serving

1 large egg, lightly beaten

2-3 Tablespoons coarse or sanding sugar

Directions

1. Preheat oven to 425 degrees (F). Line a 12" round pie plate with parchment paper.

2. Cut the puff pastry into a 10-11" square. Make 3" cuts (on the diagonal, horizontally, & vertically) on the pastry. Use the 2" extra strip of puff pastry by cutting out shapes with a small cookie or canapé cutter.

3. Place the large piece of puff pastry on top of the parchment paper.

4. Pile the cubes of the mixture of cheeses into the center of the puff pastry. 

5. Top the cheese with the minced garlic and herbs. Use your hands to lightly toss.

6. Drizzle the honey over the top of the cheese/herb/garlic mixture.

7. Fold the edges of the puff pastry over the cheese. Pinch the cuts along the edge of the puff pastry. Top the puff pastry with the extra pastry cutouts (if using).

8. Brush the puff pastry with the egg wash. Generously sprinkle with the coarse or sanding sugar. Do not use granulated sugar.

9. Bake for 30-35 minutes or until the pastry is golden brown and cheese has completely melted.

10. Remove from the oven. Place the dish on wood or slate cutting board. Garnish with some fresh herbs and/or some edible flowers. Lightly drizzle with some additional honey.

11. Serve with your favorite crackers, baguette slices and extra honey.

12. Once all the cheese has been scooped out of the cheese, use a knife to cut slices of the puff pastry to enjoy.

Notes: (1) I used a 2 part Fontina, 1 part Gruyere cheese mixture. You can also use a 50/50 cheese ratio. Fourteen ounces of cheese worked well. (2) I used a 2 part thyme, 2 part rosemary mixture. You can also use a 50/50 herb mixture ratio. Or use either all thyme or all rosemary. (3) If you can't find DuFour Puff Pastry, use another good quality puff pastry. The puff pastry from Trader Joe's is also highly rated. (4) Recipe inspired by one from Half Baked Harvest.

Directions